Ryan Murphy’s television series All’s Fair has been ranked as the worst TV show of 2025 according to Metacritic. The series received a score of 17 out of 100, placing it at the bottom of the annual ranking of the lowest-rated television projects of the year.
Metacritic’s list evaluates television series based on aggregated critical reviews. With its score of 17 points, All’s Fair occupies the first position in the ranking, making it the lowest-rated show among all titles included in the 2025 list.
Second place in the ranking went to Monsters: The Ed Gein Story, which received a score of 28 points. The third position was taken by The Hunting Party, earning 34 points. These scores place both projects among the most poorly reviewed television series of the year, though neither scored as low as All’s Fair.
The complete ranking of the worst TV series of 2025 on Metacritic is as follows:
- All’s Fair — 17 points
- Monsters: The Ed Gein Story — 28 points
- The Hunting Party — 34 points
- Simon Cowell: The Next Act — 36 points
- The Baldwins — 37 points
- With Love, Meghan — 39 points
- The Abandoned — 43 points
- The Z-Suite — 44 points
- Celebrity Bear Hunt — 44 points
- The Final Countdown — 44 points
Several of the listed shows received closely grouped scores, particularly in the lower half of the ranking, where multiple projects earned between 43 and 44 points. Despite this clustering, All’s Fair stands out with a significantly lower score than any other series on the list.
The Metacritic ranking reflects the critical reception of these shows throughout 2025, based on professional reviews rather than audience ratings. The list highlights which television projects received the weakest critical response during the year.
As published by Metacritic, this ranking positions All’s Fair as the most critically unsuccessful television series of 2025.
